Here in the UK, we have the highest net household income in Europe. Congratulations, right?
A survey shows that we earn £10,000 more on average than workers in nine of our neighbouring countries. In a recession, that must be a relief.
But a new study shows that this can't buy us more quality of life than our European neighbours. Workers and pensioners in neighbouring countries seem to be enjoying longer holidays, earlier retirement and lower costs of living than we do. In fact, in the quality of life league table, we're seriously lagging!
Could it be that earning less would help us to be happier? Or is it more complicated than that?
Findings
The study, commissioned by uSwitch, compares the UK to nine other European countries on these 17 factors designed to measure quality of life:
- Household income after tax
| | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
On the first measure, net household income, it's remarkable how far ahead of the pack the UK finds itself. Household earnings of £35,730 (based on a two-earner married couple, one part-time, with two children) are fully £10,325 above the European average, and nearly double that of Spain, the lowest in the table with £16,789.
However, it's the other factors that let the UK down. We work harder and longer, for a start. Our working week isn't the longest, but our statutory holiday entitlement is lowest, even after including our 8 public holidays. And our retirement is 6 months later than average, behind only the Swedes and the Dutch.
Plan for a better retirement – get guides and advice here »
Costs of living are another bugbear for the UK in the survey. Only fuel, energy, food, drink and cigarettes are measured, so the costs of housing and other consumer goods are missing from the picture. Nevertheless, we pay above average for a basket of groceries, a bottle of wine and a smoke than the average European consumer.
You could argue that beer, wine and cigarettes aren't essential for quality of life, and to some extent neither is petrol or diesel, but we certainly pay more for one essential — household energy bills. On gas prices, we're actually below average, but on electricity only Ireland and Italy pay more. At 15.3p per kWh, the UK's average price is two pence over average.
Pay less on your electricity or dual fuel: calculate the difference »
State healthcare spending is also lower in the UK than average, at 8.2 per cent of GDP. Again, this isn't a definitive measure of life quality; but it does make you wonder whether you'll be adequately provided for compared to, say, a German, Dane or Frenchman.
Thought about private health insurance? Get a quick quote on what that would cost »
Clearly these 17 measurements aren't a complete picture of life quality. I'd add a couple more to that list — time spent in traffic jams, for example, or cost of public transport. I'd be interested in which countries have lower crime rates, more affordable housing and classier romance novels. Nevertheless, are these findings enough to tell us that perhaps some of our neighbouring countries do enjoy a better life despite lower after-tax earnings?
Looking beyond income...
Let's take a look at uSwitch's table-topper on the overall balance of measures. Why does France seem to have it so good?
They retire earlier than we do, at an average age of 59.4 years. They live longer, by a whole two years - the French life expectancy of 80.9 years is the longest in Europe. Perhaps that's related to the table-topping 11 per cent of GDP their nation spends on healthcare?
Either way, that gives the French on average 5 extra years of retired living than we can expect. They're not top of the table for holidays (34 days a year) or sunshine (1,967 hours a year), but they certainly have more of both than we do (28 days and a relatively gloomy 1,476 hours by comparison).
Is a longer retirement a big part of quality of life? What do you think?
And how about Spain — second in the league table? Does it really come down to sunshine, long life and wine?
They actually work more hours in the week than we do, but that's offset by their holiday allowance — an impressive 41 days a year, when public holidays are added to the statutory minimum for employees. Maybe there's a relation between this and the lower Spanish average household income, but hey — would you rather have the cash, or the time off?
Sunshine of course is a natural advantage that no amount of economic meddling could change. But the Spaniards have a couple of other ways to keep smiling. They pay less for fuel and household energy. And you might not be surprised to find they enjoy the lowest prices on a bottle of wine or a round of beer — paying nearly 40 per cent less than in the UK!
What's more important for you?
Longer life, cheaper goods or a higher income?
Would you sacrifice household earnings for some of that elusive quality of life? Or do you think recession is already persuading us to do that?