Bank penalty charges - the saga continues!
A few of us here at the Money Hospital liken the bank penalty charges issue to the Star Wars saga, with the evil empire and the rebels locked in a deadly struggle (although we will leave it to you to decide who is whom?!!)
As many of you aware, banks are generally losing when it comes to court cases (normally as they don't bother to turn up!) but there have been a couple of cases where a Judge has ruled in favour of the banks.
However, campaigners led by the Consumer Action Group (CAG) persuaded a judge at Hull County Court to allow their 44 cases to be heard.
The same judge had initially wanted to follow a recent case in Birmingham, (where Lloyds TSB defeated claimant Kevin Berwick who was demanding a refund of £2,545) and strike out the cases in favour of the banks.
But his u-turn saw banks in 37 of the cases settling out of court, netting £50,000 for those account holders hit by penalties as high as £39 (some for being overdrawn by perhaps just 1p!)
Marc Gander, founder of the CAG said: "With financial help from website MoneySavingExpert.com, we hired top banking QC Raymond Fox to fight the strike-out orders"
But the Yorkshire and Clydesdale banks (who were cited in 4 of the cases) have vowed to fight on, with them claiming "our charges are fair and legal. Customers agree with them when they open accounts".
However, they will have to choose between revealing their costs or settling out of court as the judge imposed a disclosure order forcing them to reveal their true costs!
This is the crucial point of the whole penalty charges campaign as many of you argue that penalties are greater than the real cost of bouncing a cheque or setting up an overdraft which, internal bank documents show, is around £3.
So, if a bank finally has to disclose its true costs of administering overdraft fees etc, will it mean thousands more of you being able to successfully claim back your penalty charges?
Or will there be another episode in the saga that we haven't foreseen yet?
Bank penalty charges: do you want Tom Brennan to win?
Are banks finally owning up to penalty charges?