Egg cancels 161,000 credit cards

by Money Doctor Tuesday 05 February, 2008

Comedy guinea pig adverts they might have, but many of you are not finding Egg's latest policy very funny at all.

We've mentioned Egg before when their savings account gave a few of you cause for concern.

Now, Egg is withdrawing 161,000 credit cards from those of you who it believes pose an unacceptably "high risk".

The internet bank has given 7% of its credit card customers 35 days' notice that it is ending their card agreements. If you are an Egg cardholder, you will be able to continue making minimum monthly repayments on your balances but will not be able to spend any more after the deadline.

"Egg is not asking for immediate repayment of balances or making any changes to their current terms and conditions or interest rates," Egg said. They also defended their latest move by saying:

"The credit profiles of affected customers had deteriorated between the time they joined Egg and the acquisition (by Citigroup) in May. The decision to end these customers' agreements was taken after conducting a one-off, extensive risk review of our (customers)..."
The move follows a "one-off" review after Egg was bought by US-based Citigroup for £575m last year and is just another example of how lenders are revamping their lending criteria due to the ongoing credit crunch.

The 35-day notice period starts on receipt of the letter, which also provides details of how to appeal against the decision (although we have heard rumours that when you call them to appeal they tell you that you can't).

Egg says that those of you who are having your card cancelled have been told that you have had a deteriorating credit profile since you signed up. This could include those who have missed repayments or exceeded their credit limit.

However many of you have said that you had had received a letter informing you of the withdrawal, despite having an excellent credit history and have complained that you are not 'high risk' but settle your debts every month and incur no banking charges. Many of you feel that you are being axed simply because you do not make any money for Egg.

You only have to read why people are saying about Egg on blogs to see how messed up this situation is.

And because of this, many of you are considering switching to another credit card; if this is you, why not compare other credit cards here?

Egg's decision could be a signal of the tightening credit market, with consumers facing more difficulty in repaying debts and cutting spending.

Egg are keen to point out that credit card holders who have had their accounts cancelled were being told that the move would not have a bad effect on their credit rating.

Credit reference agency Experian said that cancellation of a card by the issuer would be recorded on a credit report as a "settled" account, once any outstanding balance had been cleared.

Any lender checking the customer's record in future would not see the name of the card issuer, only that the card had been settled. This is the same as if the cardholder had cancelled the card himself.

James Jones at Experian said:

'[Lenders] all make their own decisions on whether they want to grant credit or a credit card, based on credit reference agency information and other information provided by applicants. "In fact, depending on the circumstances of the individual and policies of the lender, it could have a positive effect on your credit rating as a lender might view an application from someone with a lower number of cards as more attractive."
So, are you an Egg customer who has had their card cancelled?

Why not tell us how you feel in the comments below?

If you are looking for a new credit card, below are a few options you should consider:

Barclaycard Platinum Card (6.3% interest on balance transfers until paid in full with no handling fee, 14.9% APR typical variable)

Capital One Bank Platinum MasterCard (0% on balance transfers until 1st November 2008 and 0% on purchases until 1st November 2008, Free Identity Theft Service, A low 9.9% APR typical variable)

Claim back your credit card and mortgage exit fees

Categories for this post: Credit Cards

Related posts

Comments

alan clark says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 14:02

I got one of these letters today, and only 4 months ago I checked experian to find out I was in the top 5% in the country for my credit rating!

This kind of freaked me out that something had hapenned to sour my credit history. I just paid AGAIN to check my credit report and it is still exemplary, but the fact I continually clear the cards balance has probably went against me!

5 years, no missed payments then a f***you very much from them!

Thankyou egg you scumbags!

Disgruntled

jonathon says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 15:02

what an absolute con by egg i made direct debit payments every month above the minimum and this is how you get treated.obviously i wasnt spending enough on my card to be appreciated by egg.two words.XXXXING XXXXHOLES.

Linda says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 15:02

I've had an Egg card for 6 years (maybe longer) and NEVER missed a payment. I got a letter today - on my birthday too!!!

I'd emailed egg previously to this as they kept increasing the apr (extortionately high) and they said i was a high risk - because of my entire credit file - funny how i just managed to get a mortgage and a car loan.
I think this will have a serious impact for egg (lets hope so) as if you hit bad times in a few years and you have a card with egg at least u have the knowledge that they'll cancel your card!!!

If you still have an egg card i would seriously look at transfering your balance to a better company!!

jasy says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 15:02

yes we see yet another outcome of the credit crunch, if you just need to have the flexibility of a credit card without the debt then i would recomend the virgin pre pay credit card just load the card with a debit card or standing order, spend as you like

Diggs says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 16:02

I may be tempting fate, but so far I have not recieved a letter from Egg, I pay off my debt each month also, but I do have a savings account with them - so perhaps this helps.

It is interesting to hear that many of you have had your APR increased, I'm not trying to boarst, but mine has remained steady at 10.4% for a while now.

Perhaps it is the saving account that makes the difference? But then again I may get a letter tomorrow!

Heather Smith says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 16:02

I got my letter three days after paying off my card IN FULL!!!! I have held my account with Egg for over 4 years and always paid the minimum payment by direct debit in addition to making regular extra payments when the card had a balance on it. It is quite obvious that the problem is with Egg, not my credit history. I was a bit shocked at first, but I feel better knowing that I am only one of 160,000! I was going to close my account anyway as Egg had raised my interest rate from 17.9% to 21.9% in January without letting me know, which I believe is illegal...

janet says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

I have no outstanding balance on my egg card yet received the letter. I like many others have never missed a payment. I think that Egg just can't the truth - if you don't make money for them they're not interested.

Diggs says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

Has anyone had a card cancelled who also has a savings account? I think there might be a link?

Nic says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

Hmmm, strange. I have had an account with Egg for many years (6 or 7 I guess) and have only used the card twice - both times for balance transfers (fairly sizeable). Both times I have paid over the minimum payment each month until the balances are paid up.

I have just cleared my account for the second time last month.

So far, I don't have a letter ... wonder what tomorrow holds?

Oh, I don't have a savings account with Egg, my APR is still around the 17% mark (no changes there) and I guess I would be a high risk customer since I am not working at the moment being a stay at home mum!

There seems to be no consistence to their reasoning!

kev says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

i have had a letter from egg cancelling my card i rang them they said due to credit rating they were stopping card i went on to experian credit rating 899 out of a 1000 rated as good payer no missed payments i would think this was quite a good rating the only thing is it cost me £5.99 to check wonder if egg will give me this back as they told me that is who they used to check my credit rating ( what do you think ) i will be paying off there card soon so there not gonna make to much out of me with there interest rates

Anna says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

I got the same letter - I havent used the card for over 2 years - But make regular payments on a small old debt - Surely they are in breach of their lending agreement? And there shouldnt have th right to continue to charge interest charges? Does anyone know how we all fair on this? Are thye in breach on contract too???
Their letters are extemely blunt and now their website is not functioning either with a "Sorry" notification....who has confidence now???

Anna says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

They also increased my APR without telling me, surely someone has to get all this out in the open and make EGG pay - Also their online customer services is appauling....as is there response time - and now the website isnt responding...great online BANK....

John says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

I received 1 of these letters today. My wife and I have joint cards with a total balance of -£400. We have a gross combined income of over £50,000 and equity of over £300,000 and pay by monthly direct debit and never missed a payment yet they say we are high risk ???. The problem with egg is not that I am a risk but more a case of I don't make them enough money. I have been with them for almost 10yrs and cleared my account in full on numerous occasions maybe it was time for a change anyway.

Alan says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 17:02

If anybody is declined credit from another finance house because EGG have determined wrongly that they are a credit risk then EGG are immediately guilty of libel. SUE THEM!! EGG are promoting the fact that they have closed your account because they deem you to be a credit risk this can easily be claimed as libel.

Belal Ali says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 18:02

I may also be tempting fate, but i have had a card since egg started and have always paid every month off in full, infact i have made money from egg (from all the cash back they give). I have yet to receive a letter i will or not who knows, but i have a better credit card now which gives much more so if they cancel i'm not bothered, just less adminstration for me.

Ian says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 18:02

I have had a similar problem with the Halifax One card. They cut my credit limit down to £13 above my outstanding balance, knocking £1200 off my available spend. This was at end of November with no warning (only found out when I tried to use the card) great news just before Xmas. And to top it all my MBNA card has been stopped even though I have had a very low balance, less than £100 for the last 6 months ... But they say there is no crisis looming ...

george says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 19:02

Ive got about £10.00 on my egg card, its always been paid on time by direct debit with no trouble what so ever & now its been cancelled. Its no big deal to me but i dont think they are telling the truth about why the cards are being cancelled. Maybe its citygroup who want big spenders only ? or people who dont pay regular so they can make their cash back soon...

Sian says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 20:02

I received a letter from egg saying they will be cancelling my egg card, I telephoned them on the day I received the letter and they said that there had been a change in my credit profile. I said I cant believe this as I had only recently changed my mortgage to the Woolwich.

I contacted experian to check my credit history report and according to there records my credit scoring was high!!!

So I have no clue as to why they are cancelling my card????

Lorraine says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 20:02

I have recently had the same with my Barclay card. They have reduced my spending amount from £1000 - £250....I contacted them to ask why? They said they do credit checks every 6months and agreed that the 3 years of being with them i have never missed a payment....I always paid my balance every month! HSBC has stopped my overdraft facility. I contacted experian and equafax both credit services say i have a high credit rating! What is happening to the financial state of GB.....Anyone know?

claire says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 20:02

yeah they increase your apr without letting you know then say they are closing your account at which stage the apr will remain the same ! shower of b**t**d*. thanks very much

Sarah says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 21:02

I haven't received a letter, but found out that EGG had stopped my card when i logged onto the website to find out what my balance was. I too have been subjected to higher APR in the last 2 months but the funniest thing is that I asked them to reduce my limit last month so that I would not be tempted to run up a high debt in the months after Christmas. Now, I have no available funds and I'm told that 35 days after receipt of my letter, the card will cease - funny I still haven't had my letter and can't get through to EGG on the telephone - when exactly will time start running!!

Lucy says:

Wednesday 06 February, 2008 / 23:02

My husband had his card cancelled a few weeks ago, we didnt get a letter but they rang him up and asked loads of questions about his finances then told him, because he had recently used his card to withdraw cash (debit card had been stopped due to fraud on the account) that they were cancelling his EGG card, this was after they had already put up the apr to something like 27%. I have an EGG card but so far havent received "the letter" yet i dont work and have no savings so surely I am a higher risk than my husband who does work??? Dont know whats going on, they used to be such a good company

anna says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 00:02

i haven't been banned yet but hearing what is happening with Egg I would not be surprised is they dropped me!.I have all my direct debits set up on the current account where my monthly wages is paid in, incuding my Egg Loan repayment and Egg credit card. My credit is perfect but few months ago I switched jobs and this delayed my wages being paid in my current account of 2 days, although I had paid my credit card repaiment(my balance was only £800) i was 13 hours late on my loan repayment.
When Egg customer service called me(the morning after my missed payment, on a Saturday) I had realised that my wages had been paid late so I made a payment on the spot using my other account.
RESULT: without a warning, Egg dropped my credit limit from 15000 to 5000.
When I called asking for a explanation they said, that i was a customer at high risk and they have to protect theirselves, I explained that in over 5 years I had not miss one payment and anyway the miss payment(well actually 13hours late) was on my loan balance not my credit card and they cut the conversation short being really rude,making me feel like a begger on the street!
What a shame!I actually really liked Egg and gave up 2 other major credit cards to stick with them.

anna says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 01:02

I received one of these letters today...can't help thinking that maybe this is a bigger problem than they are actually admitting to....maybe they are going under and are blaming us for their misfortunes! I wouldn't be surprised if evry egg card holder receives one of these letters!
Have to say i had plenty to say to them when they raised the APR on my card last year...not happy!!
I have always paid on time and when i last calculated how much they were making out of the interest they charge i was horrified. Needless to say i will be either swapping my card or paying it all off...sod them having my money!!

mike says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 02:02

i received the dreaded letter right out of the blue. i thought someone had cloned my card and i had gone over my limit. i rang egg to find out. i was in credit and no one had cloned the card. i asked them to explain but the robot on the phone gave me the the tosh that he had been told to give. Then quite patronisingly i was told if i had any financial dificulties then there depart ment could help??? i explaind to the nothing has changed apart from the fact that my card has been cancelled. i am a member of experian and i regually look at my credit file. theres nothing bad on there i may not be in the top 5 but i am in the top 25 percent. the deciaion does not make any sence. i am very disapointed with egg and i would not recomend egg to even my worse enemy. they are a waste of time. im currently looking for a card provider to transfer my egg card balance to, any offers????

Robbing Bastards!!!!!

i hope everyone transfers the balance!!!

DAVID EVANS says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 08:02

Bank of scotland have carried out the same action with me despite having a loan with them previously which was completed on direct debit and settled with no payments missing.My credit card has not been used for some months but has been in credit for that time so there is no way they can say i have been over limit or not paying on time,They state they are reducing my credit limit and closing my account which is bemusing how you can reduce a closed account.I have a good credit rating as I have had this checked since their letter.Obviously i am not making them money by being in credit.I have now had to send a firm letter requesting the money the owe me.

kim says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 11:02

Another thing to add...........they told me they had increased my limit a year or two ago and I spent more money on the card! Then, when I called them to pay off balance they said that they had decided my limit was not to be increased and therefore I had spent over the limit!!!! Just like that!!! They apologised and said it was a admin error and said that a letter is automatically generated when the limit goes up but then it goes to an independant team to look at the persons account to verifty this. In the meantime, the account holder thinks their limit has gone up and continues to spend.

Very dirty game. I wish I had taken this further with them at teh time. Especially now!

Kim says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 11:02

I have been with Egg for years and not missed one payment as it was always on DD. I cleared any balances way last year and I cleared a £1000 loan I had wtih them also. I only started using my card again at Christmas when I used it to book a flight. And now im being told its cancelled to to missed payments or something!!! This is not the case. Surely, legally, they cannot do this?

Anyway, Im sure that they will loose thousands of future customers and Citi have also lost trust and respect from half the nation who has been following the news.

Bad move Egg.........! Very bad move!

marktristan says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 11:02

Gosh, it's looking like a bit of a PR disaster this, isn't it?

Thanks for all the comments! A lot of people feel they've been unfairly picked on. It's absolutely not illegal what Egg are doing. I wonder if the truth might be that they wouldn't be able to keep their cashflow going if everyone was to spend, say), up to half their remaining credit limit, so they need to take some pre-emptive action... Unfortunately it seems they are making a mess of the whole thing and offending many loyal customers in the process.

A time-honoured quote to bear in mind:

"A bank is a place where they lend you an umbrella in fair weather and ask for it back when it begins to rain".

-- Robert Frost, American poet, b.1874, d.1963.

Danny Heading says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 11:02

I have been with egg for about 7 years.
Cleared the balance about 6 months ago, have not really used it since.
Did a credit check, and I'm 400+ in score.

A very bad move!

amber says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 13:02

just thought i'd say that i am frequently going over my limit, mostly pay the minimum payment with a few extra payments but so far have not had my card cancelled. if i go over the limit then they tend to increase the limit for me so i stop incurring charges!

i'm 21, rent a flat with my husband and we have joint income of 37k.

it seems to me that if you are making them money then you're kept but if you are a good payer then *bye bye*

Luisa says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 13:02

Oh my God, I thought it was just me. I worked out my min payment with Egg and the interest they are charging and I am paying them £78 a month and the interest is £76, How the hell does that work. Their interest rates are now up to 21.9% which is daylight robbery. Started years ago at 13%. Am trying to do a balance transfer as I dont see why they should make £1000 a year and I pay off £24. Is there anything that I can do?

Oddly enough before Christfmas I tried to transfer my cc onto my egg loan which only has a year left, and I was told this would not be possible!!! Wonder why that is then.

Am sooooo hacked off someone needs to do something.

Help.

terry says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 18:02

Well Well i got one what a shock never missed a beat 999 credit score on Experian and been self employed for 42 years and never not never failed to honour my debts. Fraid to say its stinks as does the rest of the stuff thats sinking this once proud country .We are led by a bunch of weak spineless MEN ????????? no chance . Im a dealing man a handshake was always good enough but nowdays if you cant come up to some computer generated financial standing your a risk!!!!!.They are the risk playing with our income raising the rates at will and making the poor sods that have had the letters pretty miserable at this already precarious and unstable time we are living in .Thank you egg if you go the same way as the ROCK good ridance you wont be missed

Eric Robinson says:

Thursday 07 February, 2008 / 21:02

A £1000 credit limit and a balance of -£800. A joint income in excess of £70,000 - a very good credit rating - sound familiar anybody?. No missed payments. And they cancel my card. Well.... if I ever get mail offering me an Egg card in the future I think I know what the reply will be - along with 161,000 others. Egg should be smashed and scambled.......

Mandy Williams says:

Friday 08 February, 2008 / 02:02

I don't have a great credit rating as I am paying off another card on reduced payments. I owe about £600 on my Egg Visa card, but my Egg Mastercard is several hundred pounds in credit. I have not received one of their letters as yet. I had a problem with Morgan Stanley who reduced my credit limit considerably even although I was paying more than minimum payment each month. I paid it off & closed the account as complaining got me nowhere.

Terry Glen says:

Friday 08 February, 2008 / 15:02

I am guessing that you dont have to make payment in full but you will still be charged the interest in full, you think they would have the decency if they are withdrawing your cards to at least say 'ok you can pay the minimum balance each month but we wont charge you interest' i'm living in fairy land again i guess.

Terry says:

Friday 08 February, 2008 / 21:02

Hmm, all these people PAYING to check their credit ratings due to egg cancelling cards, who's being given commission from experian. Anybody we know do ya think !

Gary says:

Saturday 09 February, 2008 / 18:02

It's clear Egg (driven by CityCorp) are getting rid of low value customers. i.e. those that always pay off there entire balance or have very low volume transactions.

I can understand being lied to (bad risk line) makes people irriated; but it's just business.

Even if you have not had an infamous letter from Egg, why not bin Egg. Send a message to the banking world.

Suzy says:

Tuesday 12 February, 2008 / 00:02

A relative of mine has just received one of these letters. The 'reason' for cancelling his card as we all now is an outright lie. His credit rating actually improved in the period of time quoted for the reassesment. In the same period my friends rating got worse (due to a domestic break up) and she was actually offered a card! Egg, if you want to ditch people who you don't make enough money from just say so, if you lie no-one will ever trust you again!

lulu says:

Tuesday 12 February, 2008 / 16:02

I have an outstanding balance on my Egg card of -£2,500. I have made a number of late payments, incurring the £12 penalty fee each time. Egg have not cancelled my card! I also have a loan with them. I make them lots of money, my history with them is not an exemplary model, so there is indeed no reason to get rid of me! Just the sort of 'integrity' I expect from any bank!

stephen hodgkiss says:

Tuesday 12 February, 2008 / 18:02

Yes my Egg card has been cancelled. i believe no company is allowed to check your credit file anyway, without your consent. There credit checking as what's been talked about, I'm sure will be based on their own records. I have 2 loans with them as well, no major problems with payments, certainly nothing to justify closing my account. I did a balance transfer in September for £11k that is coming to an end now. they increased by interest rate as well to 21.9% with no valid reason after I sent them an email. a few weeks later and now look

Greg says:

Tuesday 12 February, 2008 / 19:02

Possibly the worst company ive ever dealt with! first they hike my apr up from 16.9 to 21.9% without any notice after i have just paid nearly 2 grand off on my card then i get a lovley letter telling me im a bad credit risk (after ive just been approved for a mortgage 2 months before) the bloody cheeky of them! well i hope everyone who has savings with these cowboys does the decent thing and moves it all to somewhere else! maybe that will teach Egg a lesson on how to treat customers eh?

Darren says:

Wednesday 13 February, 2008 / 08:02

Funny, my Egg card has been in credit for over a year (yes in credit) and I got an offer from Egg through the postthe other day offering me 0% on balance transfers for nine months. I promptly transferred a balance from another card and I couldn't be happier. I've always found the service from Egg to be second to none unlike some other card companies I could mention...

debbie says:

Tuesday 19 February, 2008 / 16:02

Went on holiday on the 8th of feb,came home to a letter from egg cancelling my card giving me 35 days notice,i have been with egg for about 6 years,i have never missed a payment and always pay well above the minimum payment.I checked my credit report to find my score is 917 out of 1000.well egg can take a run and jump i hope they go under.
Thanks for nothing EGG.

Add comment

(required)

(required, will not be published)
 
(optional)

[b][/b] - [i][/i] - [u][/u]- [quote][/quote]



Live preview

says:

Monday 13 October, 2008 / 00:20


Recent comments